Make Your Own Yummy Popsicles: Popsicle Molds and Recipes

plastic-free popsicle molds

Want to make your own yummy popsicles but haven’t found a good popsicle mold? Here’s our review of several plastic-free molds, and one that’s BPA-free, plus a couple of recipes we really like.

Why popsicles?

Duh! Why not?!! They’re refreshing, fun, and when they’re not loaded with sugar and artificial food coloring like the ones you might buy in the store, they’re a healthy and eco-friendly snack.

Popsicles are one of the easiest make-it-yourself treats both because they’re quick (not counting freezing time), and because they use up fruit that might be too ripe to eat but very easy to puree. All you need to make popsicles is:

♥ some kind of mold to put the popsicle mixture in;

♥ a mixture of whatever you’d like to eat in your popsicle;

♥ a blender of some sort to puree the ingredients so you can pour them into your popsicle mold;

♥ a funnel so you can easily pour the puree into the mold.

What Can You Put in Your DIY Popsicles?

popsicle recipes* fruit – fresh or frozen

* juice plus pureed fruit

* yogurt plus fruit

* tea

* melted chocolate blended with peanut butter and bananas

* tofu, wheat germ, nuts or other foods to sneak a little nutritional power into your popsicle

* anything else you think would be good to eat frozen.

You can also experiment by adding different herbs, like mint, rosemary, and cilantro, to the popsicle mixture for an interesting tang.

Plastic-Free Popsicle Molds

When we were growing up, my mom used ice cube trays to freeze juice so we could have mini popsicles. These days, there are lots of different popsicle molds for sale – check your local hardware store, or buy online (we sell some in our Amazon store here).

I recently tested three different popsicle molds: the Onyx stainless steel (which the manufacturer provided me free of charge), a set of silicone push-up molds, and some traditional looking, BPA-free molds, both of which I bought at my local hardware store. (I ordered some Freezycup Stainless Steel molds, but they didn’t arrive in time for this post.)

I washed out all the molds then set them up so I could fill them once I made the mixture for my favorite Lemon-Strawberry Yogurt Pops.


About two cups fresh strawberries, washed, hulled and cut in half

Juice of 1/2 lemon, about 2 tablespoons juice

Sweetener if you want – 2 tablespoons honey, maple syrup, or raw agave nectar

1 cup plain, non-fat Greek yogurt


I pureed the strawberries, pulsed in the lemon juice and honey, then added the yogurt. I blended everything until it was smooth enough to pour into the molds.

I used a teaspoon to fill each mold; next time, I’m going to use a funnel, which will make less of a mess!

Once they were filled, I popped all of the molds into the freezer.


All of the popsicles froze in about the same amount of time – 3 1/2 hours.

I ran each popsicle under warm water for a few seconds to loosen it from its mold.

All of the popsicles tasted the same, of course. And though the molds were shaped differently, each one made a pretty big popsicle. (You can make the popsicles smaller by putting less filling in each mold. You don’t want to overfill, since liquids expand when they freeze). I thought that the square blocks and the silicone push-ups were easier to eat than the Onyx, but the Onyx are probably a little environmentally safer. Here are the pros and cons of each mold:

plastic-free popsicle moldSILICONE PUSH UP MOLDS – PROSThese popsicles were the easiest to eat and the least messy to use. As the popsicle melts, it pretty much drips down into the bottom of the mold, and it’s easy to slurp up the juice at the bottom after you’ve finished the popsicle. Plus, there’s no after-taste from the food touching the silicone. Also, there are no sticks required, so there’s less waste. And the molds come in a simple box that you can use for storage or completely recycle.

CONS – Right now, the jury is still out on the safety of food-grade silicone, since its use is relatively new and few studies have been done on whether it has human health impacts. I don’t use silicone baking sheets or other silicone utensils if they are going to be exposed to high heat, as heat changes the chemical nature of all kinds of products and renders some of them harmful (think Teflon). But for popsicles, where the environment is a frozen one and the major process at work is freezing rather than heating, I think silicone would be fine. Another con is that only four molds come in a box. If you want to make more popsicles at one time, you’d need to buy two boxes of molds.

onyx popsicle moldONYX STAINLESS STEEL MOLDS – PROS – These molds are stainless steel, which, along with glass, seems to be universally accepted as the safest food container to use. They make big popsicles.They come six to a tray, so as long as you have room in your freezer for the tray, you can make a lot of popsicles at once.

CONS: The Onyx mold has a little stainless steel tray at the base of the stick that’s designed to catch drips. But I found that when I tipped the popsicle sideways, the liquid on the tray dripped all over me. Also, I found it hard to get to the very bottom of the popsicle, since it was so close to the tray. The Onyx came packaged in lots of trashy plastic bags, which surprised me. Also, it uses wooden popsicle sticks that the manufacturer says can be re-used as long as they haven’t been chewed on. I tried washing my popsicle stick after I used it, but it didn’t hold up very well. I don’t think I’d use it more than twice without tossing it. I imagine most kids will chew up their sticks any way (mine sure did when they were little.)

stainless steel popsicle moldFREEZY CUPS STAINLESS STEEL MOLDS – PROS – I did not have a chance to try these out personally. According to the manufacturer, “Ours do not require to be installed in a tray and can be frozen individually in the freezer.  The lid is very similar (to the Onyx). The sticks are reusable bamboo and the molds stand in the refrigerator on their own.” This individual mold would be good if you wanted to make a few popsicles but not necessarily a whole trayful. Freezycups are mailed in a plastic-free package.  Another BIG Pro in favor of Freezycups is that proceeds benefit the work of Life Without Plastic, a wonderful company that is devoted to ridding the world of plastic.

CONS: Even though they say the sticks are reusable bamboo, I found that I probably wouldn’t use the stick more than twice before throwing it away. They may also have the same drip tray problem as the Onyx molds.

BOA-free Plastic Popsicle MoldBPA-FREE PLASTIC MOLDS – PROS: This makes a big rectangular popsicle that is particularly well-suited for creamy, fruit-filled popsicles. It’s easy to eat the entire popsicle without interference from a catch tray at the bottom. CONS: Well, it is still plastic, BPA-free or no. Also, the molds are part of a tray that must be used in the freezer all together. If you don’t have room for the entire tray, you can’t use the mold.


BOTTOM LINE: Making your own popsicles offers lots of benefits. You can make safe and healthy popsicles free of excess sugar and food coloring from the fresh ingredients you love most. You can use up fruit you might otherwise have to throw away. You can sneak in some extra nutrients to make popsicles that pack a nutritional punch.  You can avoid a lot of throwaway packaging, since once you buy the mold, you don’t have to buy boxes of popsicles that may come wrapped in plastic or in cardboard coated with thin plastic film. Making popsicles is something the entire family can do together. Even a two- or three-year old can help fill popsicle molds!

There are lots of plastic-free popsicle molds on the market. I recommend the silicone push-ups, the Freezycups, or the Onyx stainless steel molds rather than BPA-free plastic or regular plastic. If you use the Freezycups on the Onyx stainless steel molds, experiment with reusable butter knives or teaspoons as an alternative to throwaway sticks.

By the way, here are a couple of fun books full of delicious recipes to make your own yummy popsicles:

DIY Popsicle Recipes Yummy Popsicles


, , , , ,

7 Responses to Make Your Own Yummy Popsicles: Popsicle Molds and Recipes

  1. Paige July 12, 2012 at 7:58 am #

    I’m a popsicle making machine! Loving the new Onyx ones as they come out of the mold super easy. Also for my kid the trick is to hide chucks of contrasting fruit – he’s really into seeing pieces of banana in a cherry pop for instance!

  2. Beth Terry July 20, 2012 at 11:54 am #

    Thanks for this write up, Diane. Love the comparisons. I have used the Onyx ones but didn’t care for the plastic-coated rack or how big it was for my freezer. Looking forward to trying the Freezy Cups.

  3. reiki music December 12, 2012 at 6:04 pm #

    Your post just reminds me of my childhood playing on the streets and waiting for our neighbor to sell me and other kids Popsicle. I may also try your recipe for my children.

  4. Tina December 30, 2012 at 12:35 am #

    Just a question: Is there a difference between wooden and plastic popsicle sticks? Which is better?

  5. Diane MacEachern January 3, 2013 at 8:44 am #

    I prefer wooden, because they are biodegradable. But the best would be some kind of stainless steel that could be washed and re-used.

  6. honey onyx June 2, 2013 at 6:52 am #

    Nice article and great knowledge. Thanks for the share. I love this story and enjoy with your words!

  7. Diane June 10, 2014 at 11:08 am #

    Good. I’m glad you enjoy it.